Where the Alfonsine Tables Got Their Andalusi Astronomy
Alfonso X's astronomers corrected a 200-year-old Andalusi work. Follow the Alfonsine Tables' sources from al-Zarqali's Córdoba years to Toledo, 1263-1272.
The Castilian canons of the Alfonsine Tables survive in one manuscript, BNE MS 3306 in Madrid; the numerical tables are lost.
- Toledo observation programme
- 1263–1272
- Span of observations named in the canons' Castilian prologue[5]
In this article
Jump to a section
Toledo in 1263: an Andalusi work under review
What Alfonso X the Wise commissioned, and from whom
Córdoba's astronomers inside the Alfonsine corpus
Explore nearby · Monument
Torre de la Calahorra
12th-century Islamic tower at the end of the Roman Bridge. Museum of Al-Andalus with rooftop views of the Mezquita and Guadalquivir. €4.50 adult entry.
What the 24-arcminute correction changes
Solar apogee, trepidation and the Alfonsine year
The Libro de las Cruzes and its Andalusi astrology
Recommended tours
Tours are selected for quality, not commission. We earn a small fee if you book — at no extra cost to you.
From Paris to Venice, and where the evidence sits today
Deep dive · Article
1808: The Sack of Córdoba That Broke a French Army at Bailén
In June 1808, French troops sacked Córdoba's churches and palaces on a flimsy pretext — and dragged the plunder into the disaster at Bailén weeks later.
- 1252
Alfonsine era begins
Alfonso X's accession year, the epoch of the tables for Toledo's meridian[45]
- 1263–1272
Toledo observation programme
Dates given in the Castilian prologue[5]
- c. 1320–1321
Latin adaptation in Paris
The version that spread across Europe[44]
- 1483
First printed in Venice
Erhard Ratdolt's edition[44]
- Biblioteca Nacional de España, Madrid, MS 3306: the Castilian canons, the only manuscript of the original Alfonsine Tables[1]
- Biblioteca Nacional de España, MS 9294: the 1259 royal scriptorium codex of the Libro de las Cruzes[41]
- Biblioteca Medicea Laurenziana, Florence, MS Or. 152: two Arabic treatises whose colophons place their copying in Toledo in 1265 and 1266, with a note by Isaac ibn Sid on the copying[46]
- Torre de la Calahorra, Córdoba: the city's Museum of Al-Andalus, for the wider Andalusi setting of this science
Frequently asked questions
Who compiled the Alfonsine Tables, and when?
What were the Andalusi sources of the Alfonsine Tables?
How do the Alfonsine Tables relate to the Toledan Tables?
What is Córdoba's connection to the Alfonsine Tables?
What is the Libro de las Cruzes?
Did the original Alfonsine Tables survive?
Who was al-Zarqali?
What is al-Zarqali's 24-arcminute lunar correction?
Why are the Alfonsine Tables called Andalusi when they use Maghribi tables?
Sources
46 references Show Hide
- revistas.ucm.es (opens in a new tab)
“Las Tablas Alfonsíes originales no se han conservado, y tan sólo contamos con un manuscrito de la Biblioteca Nacional de Madrid, Ms. 3306”
- islamsci.mcgill.ca — Alfonso X BEA (opens in a new tab)
“The few numerical parameters mentioned in the canons or in the rest of the Alfonsine works extant in Spanish derive from the Toledan Tables or from the work of the Maghribī astronomer Ibn Isḥāq”
- islamsci.mcgill.ca — Zarqali BEA (opens in a new tab)
“the displacement of the center of the lunar mean motion in longitude to a point on a straight line linking the center of the Earth with the solar apogee, and at a distance of 24'.”
- islamsci.mcgill.ca — Zarqali BEA (opens in a new tab)
“It appears also in the Spanish canons of the first version of the Alfonsine Tables”
- docta.ucm.es — Download (opens in a new tab)
“The prologue of the canons of the Alfonsine Tables specifies that the observations were made between 1263 and 1272”
- mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk — Al Zarqali (opens in a new tab)
“Recent research, however, has determined that he died on 15 October 1100.”
- islamsci.mcgill.ca — Alfonso X BEA (opens in a new tab)
“the Alfonsine tropical year of 365 days, 5 hours, 49 minutes, and almost 16 seconds was the mean tropical year used in the De revolutionibus and became the basis for the Gregorian reform.”
- docta.ucm.es — Download (opens in a new tab)
“Judah ben Moses ha-Cohen and Isaac ben Sid began observations in the city of Toledo with the aim of improving on and correcting a precedent work, the Toledan Tables.”
- revistas.ucm.es (opens in a new tab)
“E mandonos retificar en la çibdad de Toledo ques una de las çibdades prinçipales de España. guardela Dios. En ella fue el retificar de Azarquiel.”
- islamsci.mcgill.ca — Zarqali BEA (opens in a new tab)
“an adaptation of the best available astronomical material (i. e., Khwārizmī and Battānī) to the coordinates of Toledo that was made by a team led by Ṣāʿid and in which Zarqālī seems to have been a prominent member.”
- resolve.cambridge.org (opens in a new tab)
“The Toledan Tables could have been the model for the first draft of the Alphonsine zij, of which we know only the Spanish canons (Rico IV, 119-183), for in this latter text it is clearly established that the tables were used to compute sidereal longitudes.”
- arrabita.ma (opens in a new tab)
“astronomical tables ( zījes) belonging to the tradition of Ibn Is ḥāq al-Tunis ī (fl. 1193–1222) were available to the astronomers in the service of King Alfonso X”
- islamsci.mcgill.ca — Ibn Ishaq BEA (opens in a new tab)
“The whole constitutes an impressive collection of materials in which the predominant influence is clearly Andalusian, but we do not know yet to what extent Ibn Isḥāq's contributions are original.”
- inference-review.com (opens in a new tab)
“The Ṭabaqāt gives no indication that Ṣāʽid knew of any Eastern Islamic books published after 950, confirming that Andalusian culture was isolated after the fall of the Córdoban Caliphate.”
- islamsci.mcgill.ca — Alfonso X BEA (opens in a new tab)
“made a great effort to recover Arabic and, very especially, Andalusian astronomical materials by translating them into Spanish, thus becoming a pioneer in the use of the vernacular as a scientific language.”
- bne.es (opens in a new tab)
“el tercer pilar que sostuvo el modo de gobierno alfonsí fuera la ciencia de las estrellas, a la que los reyes musulmanes o cristianos recurrían para averiguar el futuro o, incluso, para modificarlo.”
- docta.ucm.es — Download (opens in a new tab)
“The first news we have of him is his participation in the Latin translation of Azarquiel’s Book of the Azafeha , together with the Christian translator, Guillelmus Anglicus, between 1225 and 1231.”
- institucional.us.es (opens in a new tab)
“Isaac ben Sid was the most prolific scientific collaborator of the wise king, with numerous works, mostly his own but also translated, on the construction of astronomical instruments and clocks.”
- docta.ucm.es — Download (opens in a new tab)
“Rabiçag, whom he quotes as Rabbi Isaac ha-hazzan b. Sîd, made the observations of the eclipses in the city of Toledo under the orders of King Alfonso, observations he recorded in his own handwriting.”
- islamsci.mcgill.ca — Ibn al Samh BEA (opens in a new tab)
“The instrument described by Ibn al‐Samḥ is a hybrid astrolabe/equatorium, and his treatise is preserved in the Alfonsine translation included in the Libros del Saber de Astronomia.”
- inference-review.com (opens in a new tab)
“his full name was Abū Is ḥāq Ibrāhīm ibn Ya ḥyā al-Naqqāsh al-Tujībī. 9 He had been born near Toledo and trained as a metalsmith”
- mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk — Al Zarqali (opens in a new tab)
“He was born in Qurtuba, the Arabic name for the city of Córdoba in Spain.”
- mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk — Al zarqali.pdf (opens in a new tab)
“obliged him to move to Córdoba sometime after 1078. There he determined the longitude of Calbalazada (Regulus) in 1080 and the culmination of the planets a year later; in 1087 he carried out his last observations.”
- islamsci.mcgill.ca — Said al Andalusi BEA (opens in a new tab)
“Azarquiel's less than voluntary move to Cordova circa 1080 because of unsettled conditions under al‐Maʾmūn's dissolute grandson Yaḥyā al‐Qādir.”
- inference-review.com (opens in a new tab)
“he left Toledo either at the beginning of the reign of al-Ma’mūn’s successor, Yaḥyā II al-Qādir (1075–1085), or as a result of the conquest of Toledo by Alfonso VI, king of Castile, in 1085.”
- mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk — Al zarqali.pdf (opens in a new tab)
“in the graphic representation included in the Castilian translation ordered by Alfonso X (The Wise) the orbit of Mercury is not circular”
- mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk — Al zarqali.pdf (opens in a new tab)
“in 1087 he carried out his last observations. This fact has led some writers to establish 1087 as the year of his death.”
- islamsci.mcgill.ca — Zarqali BEA (opens in a new tab)
“attributes to Zarqālī 25 years of solar observations and 37 years of observations of the Moon.”
- sehepunkte.de (opens in a new tab)
“Samsó highlights Ibn al-Zarqālluh's profile and considers that his texts and their further influence explain the common astronomical tradition at both sides of the Strait of Gibraltar.”
- inference-review.com (opens in a new tab)
“[He reached results] which did not disagree at all with [what] the Ancients said on this topic, with the only exception of the mean [lunar] motion in longitude.”
- islamsci.mcgill.ca — Zarqali BEA (opens in a new tab)
“we find the same correction in later Andalusian (Ibn al‐Kammād) and Maghribī (Ibn Isḥāq, Ibn al‐Bannāʾ) zījes, although restricted to the calculation of eclipses and the New Moon.”
- webspace.science.uu.nl (opens in a new tab)
“the presentation of the parisian alfonsine tables agrees exactly with that of the toledan tables although the underlying parameters are different.”
- webspace.science.uu.nl (opens in a new tab)
“Later, in the 11th century, azarquiel realized that the solar apogee had a proper motion in addition to precession, and fixed its amount as 1° in 279 Julian years or about 0;0,0,2°/d”
- islamsci.mcgill.ca — Zarqali BEA (opens in a new tab)
“It contains a study of three different trepidation models, in the third of which variable precession becomes independent of the oscillation of the obliquity of the ecliptic.”
- ircps.org (opens in a new tab)
“a value of 2;10 ◦ as maximum solar correction; and no proper movements for the apogees of the Sun and the planets.”
- arrabita.ma (opens in a new tab)
“The fact that most Alfonsine mean motions derive clearly from Ibn Is ḥāq’s parameters shows the Toledan origin of the Parisian Alfonsine mean motion tables.”
- webspace.science.uu.nl (opens in a new tab)
“based on a mean motion of 0;0,0,4,20,41,17,12°/d, corresponding to one revolution in exactly 49,000 years.”
- webspace.science.uu.nl (opens in a new tab)
“a fixed tropical year of 365d 5;49,15,59,34,3h [= 365;14,33,9,59,20,7,30d], a value that first appeared in the Expositio by John of Murs, who explicitly says that he took it from the castilian alfonsine tables”
- islamsci.mcgill.ca — Alfonso X BEA (opens in a new tab)
“they believe that the revision was made in Paris, on the basis of the Alfonsine materials mainly represented by the Castilian canons.”
- docta.ucm.es — Download (opens in a new tab)
“On 26 February 1259, he completed the Libro de las cruzes ,working again with Johan Daspa”
- docta.ucm.es — Download (opens in a new tab)
“El prólogo afirma que el texto fue hallado por Alfonso X y ordenó su traducción al castellano y su separación en 75 capítulos.”
- islamsci.mcgill.ca — Alfonso X BEA (opens in a new tab)
“a late Latin astrological handbook based on a versified Arabic version that had been written in the first half of the 9th century and subsequently revised by a certain ʿUbayd Allāh in the 11th century.”
- docta.ucm.es — Download (opens in a new tab)
“se diferencia del sistema astrológico oriental en que no presta atención a la indicación exacta del lugar de los planetas (grados y minutos) sino en qué casa se encuentran y su posición entre sí.”
- institucional.us.es (opens in a new tab)
“They were first printed in Venice in 1483; the printer, Erhard Ratdolt, had printed Euclid’s Elements the previous year.”
- revistas.ucm.es (opens in a new tab)
“por último se define la “ la hera alfonsí ” que comienza con el año en el que empezó a reinar Alfonso X, 1252”
- docta.ucm.es — Download (opens in a new tab)
“According to the colophons, two of its treatises were copied in Toledo, in 1265 and 1266, and on page 75 there is an interesting note written in Arabic with Hebrew script where Isaac ben Sid talks about the process of copying”