Skip to main content
history-buffsphotographersarchitecture
Mezquita columns spolia: rows of mismatched marble, granite and jasper shafts with different capitals under red-and-white double arches, soft warm light in the Córdoba prayer hall

The Mezquita's Columns Don't Match: They Were Never Meant To

The Mezquita's forest of roughly 850 columns looks uniform but isn't. Builders reused Roman and Visigothic spolia; new capitals came later. Where to look.

Portrait of Sophie Marchand
Written by

Art history background with eight years writing interpretive content on Córdoba's Caliphal heritage.

Updated Published
Umayyad Emirate711–929
Walk into the prayer hall of the Mezquita and the columns seem to repeat forever, roughly 850 of them.[1] Look at the shafts, though, and the stone, colour and carving shift from one to the next, because the first builders took columns from earlier Roman and Visigothic buildings.[4] That is the story of the oldest hall, not of every column: new capitals were carved from the 9th century on.[2]
Columns in the prayer hall
~850
A figure that varies by source; this is the NYRB's "some 850 in all"[1]
New capitals begin
9th century
Abd al-Rahman II's local workshops carved eleven notable new capitals[16]
Al-Hakam II's extension
45 m
Twelve more bays south, repeating the two-tier arches[3]

Look closer: a hall that only looks uniform

From the doorway the hall reads as a single idea repeated: red-and-white arches over a floor of columns. Closer in, the effect loosens. The shafts are not one stone. The hall's columns are described as made of:
  • jasper
  • onyx
  • marble
  • granite
  • porphyry
Wikipedia's summary lists them in that order.[5] Published counts differ from source to source, so treat 850 as a round figure rather than an inventory.
The heights differ too. A teaching site run by CUNY notes that the bases and capitals vary in size and detail to make up for the necessary heights.[6] Uniformity is the visitor's first impression. Matching was never the builders' brief.

Spolia: where the first columns came from

Spolia, Latin for "spoils", are stones lifted from an old structure for a new one,[7] and the practice was routine in late antiquity.[8] The first mosque, begun under Abd al-Rahman I in 785, drew on that habit. Reusing existing columns and capitals helped keep its construction short.[9]
Where did the stone come from? J.H. Elliott, writing in The New York Review of Books, describes columns and capitals pillaged from Visigothic and Roman buildings across a territory running from North Africa to Narbonne.[4] Stories naming exact donor buildings circulate, but none is established by the sources used here, so treat them as tradition.
Interior of the Mezquita-Catedral de Córdoba with its iconic red-and-white arches and forest of columns

Explore nearby · Monument

Mezquita-Catedral de Córdoba

856 columns, 1,300 years of Islamic and Christian history. UNESCO monument in Córdoba, Andalusia. Red-and-white arches, Byzantine mosaics, a Renaissance nave.

The nearest source may have been underfoot. The cathedral's own site says the basement holds the archaeological remains of the Visigothic basilica of San Vicente,[10] and a brick inscription there dates the construction to the 6th century.[11] The same site says the mosque's creative solution included reusing Roman and Visigothic materials, as in the case of that basilica.[12]
The popular tale that Muslims and Christians shared San Vicente before the mosque is a later layer. Its first mention is Ibn Idhari in the fourteenth century, citing a tenth-century historian.[13] Whether a church stood there at all is a matter of scholarly debate.[14] The full backstory is in what stood on the site before the Mezquita.
So the spolia are an ordinary late-antique habit, not a trophy collection. The surprise is how long the habit's traces stayed on show.

New capitals, same hall: from the 9th century on

The recycling did not run for ever. Under Abd al-Rahman II the builders began commissioning new marble capitals instead of only reusing ancient ones.[15] The cabildo's site singles out eleven capitals from local workshops that follow Roman proportions but use a drilled technique.[16] The same phase dropped the column bases.[17] Even so, reused material still characterised the building.[18]
That is why a blanket "all spolia" or "no two match" fails. Think of the hall as layers, with Roman and Visigothic stock at the core and new carving added as the mosque grew.
One seam is easy to find. The two pairs of columns at al-Hakam II's mihrab are said by the cathedral to have belonged to the earlier mihrab of Abd al-Rahman II,[19] and each pair holds one red and one dark green column.[20] Al-Hakam II's own extension ran 45 metres south,[3] and nothing in the sources used here says whether its capitals were new or reused. For the caliph behind it, see al-Hakam II and his vanished library.
Almanzor, al-Mansur billah, vizier of Córdoba — portrait composition in the style of Islamic illuminated manuscripts from al-Andalus, 10th century

Deep dive · Article

Almanzor: The Man Who Dismantled the Caliphate From Inside

Almanzor ran Córdoba for 25 years without claiming the caliphate. Fifty-seven undefeated campaigns, the bells of Santiago, a purged library — and civil war.

The last big enlargement, under Almanzor, adds another note. The capitals made for its hundreds of new columns are simpler and less detailed, which may reflect haste.[21] The cathedral's site adds that masons' marks are visible on shafts and capitals from this phase.[22] Abd al-Rahman II's own period is covered in Abd al-Rahman II's Córdoba.

Why two tiers? A leading explanation, not a proof

A hall full of short, mismatched shafts has a visible consequence. One leading explanation, set out by the CUNY teaching site, is that without the materials for tall monumental columns, double arches were the strategy that gained the extra height.[23]
Historians argue about how far that goes. Wikipedia notes the motive may have been technical, since the spolia available in Córdoba were not tall like those in Damascus.[24] UNESCO points elsewhere, naming the Los Milagros aqueduct at Mérida as the direct forerunner of the double arches.[25]
There is also a catch for a strict reading. Al-Hakam II repeated the two-tier design in his extension,[3] by which time the builders could carve what they wanted. A shortage may have started the idea; it cannot be the only reason it lasted. For the arch itself, read how Córdoba gave Islam its signature arch shape.

What the mismatch tells you, and where to look

UNESCO treats the reuse as proof of the monument's authenticity, an example of Roman and Visigothic columns assimilated into Islamic architecture.[26] Scholars go further. Spolia in Umayyad building is extensively documented from Bilad al-Sham to al-Andalus,[27] and reasons proposed include aesthetic, religious and ideological motives plus political legitimation of the dynasty.[28]
The contrast is Madinat al-Zahra, the palace-city, where spolia seem to have been absent and the capitals were designed for the prayer room instead.[29] The mosque on the hill was built from borrowed stone; the palace-city was not. See Medina Azahara, the lost palace city.
So in the hall, look for the following:

Recommended tours

Tours are selected for quality, not commission. We earn a small fee if you book — at no extra cost to you.

  • Shafts that change stone or colour from one row to the next.
  • Bases and capitals that differ in size and detail,[6] though Abd al-Rahman II's phase has no bases.[17]
  • The red and dark green column pairs at the mihrab.[20]
  • Masons' marks and simpler capitals in Almanzor's wing.[22]
In the oldest part, the hall of eleven naves, the superimposed arches are the first thing to read against the shafts.[30] A guided tour of the Mezquita can point these out with the building in front of you.
What the evidence cannot settle is how many columns came from which building, or whether the two-tier arch solved a shortage or was simply liked. The seams are visible. Their meanings are still argued.

Frequently asked questions

Are the Mezquita columns spolia?

Most of the original ones were. The first mosque reused columns and capitals from Roman and Visigothic buildings,[9] while later expansions starting with Abd al-Rahman II added new capitals.[2] So the hall is mixed rather than uniformly reused.

Why are the Mezquita's columns different colours and sizes?

The shafts were reused from other buildings and are made of different stones, including jasper, onyx, marble, granite and porphyry.[5] Bases and capitals vary in size and detail to compensate for the different heights.[6]

Where did the Mezquita's columns come from?

One account describes columns and capitals pillaged from Visigothic and Roman buildings across a territory from North Africa to Narbonne.[4] Exact donor buildings are not established by the sources used for this article.

Sources

30 references Show
  1. nybooks.com (opens in a new tab)

    “long, receding vistas of columns, some 850 in all”

  2. Wikipedia — Great Mosque of Córdoba (opens in a new tab)

    “All of the original columns and capitals were reused from earlier Roman and Visigothic buildings, but subsequent expansions (starting with Abd al-Rahman II) saw the incorporation of new Moorish-made capitals”

  3. Wikipedia — Great Mosque of Córdoba (opens in a new tab)

    “The hall was extended 45 meters to the south by adding 12 more bays (arches), again repeating the two-tiered arches of the original design.”

  4. nybooks.com (opens in a new tab)

    “he made use of columns and capitals pillaged from Visigothic and Roman buildings over a vast swath of territory running from North Africa to Narbonne.”

  5. Wikipedia — Great Mosque of Córdoba (opens in a new tab)

    “The current building has approximately 850 columns made of jasper, onyx, marble, granite and porphyry.”

  6. cordobamosque.commons.gc.cuny.edu (opens in a new tab)

    “The bases and capitals of the columns vary in size and detailing, in order to compensate for the necessary heights.”

  7. Wikipedia — Spolia (opens in a new tab)

    “Spolia (Latin for 'spoils'; sing.: spolium) are stones taken from an old structure and repurposed for new construction or decorative purposes.”

  8. Wikipedia — Spolia (opens in a new tab)

    “The practice of spoliation was common in late antiquity.”

  9. Wikipedia — Great Mosque of Córdoba (opens in a new tab)

    “This relatively short period of construction was aided by the reuse of existing Roman and Visigothic materials in the area, especially columns and capitals.”

  10. mezquita-catedraldecordoba.es — Basilica visigoda de san vicente (opens in a new tab)

    “In the basement of the Mosque-Cathedral Monumental Site of Cordoba are the archaeological remains of the Visigoth Basilica of San Vicente.”

  11. mezquita-catedraldecordoba.es — Basilica visigoda de san vicente (opens in a new tab)

    “which tells us the workshop where the materials came from and dates the construction to the 6th century.”

  12. mezquita-catedraldecordoba.es — Mezquita fundacional de abderraman i (opens in a new tab)

    “The highly creative solution adopted also involved the reuse of the Roman and Visigoth materials belonging to other previous constructions, as in the case of the Basilica of San Vicente.”

  13. Wikipedia — Great Mosque of Córdoba (opens in a new tab)

    “The first reference to the Muslims' sharing the church was by Ibn Idhārī in the fourteenth century, citing the tenth-century historian al-Rāzī.”

  14. Wikipedia — Great Mosque of Córdoba (opens in a new tab)

    “although this has been a matter of scholarly debate.”

  15. Wikipedia — Great Mosque of Córdoba (opens in a new tab)

    “the builders began to commission new marble capitals for the columns instead of just re-using ancient ones.”

  16. mezquita-catedraldecordoba.es — Ampliacion de abderraman ii (opens in a new tab)

    “A highlight of their work was the construction of eleven capitals which, whilst they follow the proportions of Roman art, are inspired by the boring sculpture technique.”

  17. mezquita-catedraldecordoba.es — Ampliacion de abderraman ii (opens in a new tab)

    “there was a new development with not using the bases of the columns.”

  18. mezquita-catedraldecordoba.es — Ampliacion de abderraman ii (opens in a new tab)

    “In any case, the use of sediment materials would continue to characterise the appearance of the building.”

  19. mezquita-catedraldecordoba.es — Ampliacion de abderraman ii (opens in a new tab)

    “the two pairs of columns currently located in the mihrab of Al-Hakam II belonged to it.”

  20. Wikipedia — Great Mosque of Córdoba (opens in a new tab)

    “each pair featuring one red column and one dark green column”

  21. Wikipedia — Great Mosque of Córdoba (opens in a new tab)

    “the capitals produced for the hundreds of new columns have a simpler and less detailed design that may reflect the hurry in which they were produced.”

  22. mezquita-catedraldecordoba.es — Ampliacion de almanzor (opens in a new tab)

    “the testimony of the stonemasons working on this phase, as can be seen in the markings carved into shafts and capitals.”

  23. cordobamosque.commons.gc.cuny.edu (opens in a new tab)

    “Lacking the materials necessary for tall monumental columns, the strategy of the double arches made it possible to achieve the desired additional height”

  24. Wikipedia — Great Mosque of Córdoba (opens in a new tab)

    “The motivation for the two-tiered design may have been more technical: unlike the large spolia columns available in Damascus, the columns available for reuse in Córdoba were not tall enough to raise the ceiling”

  25. UNESCO World Heritage (opens in a new tab)

    “The direct forerunners to this can be found in the Los Milagros (Miracles) Aqueduct in Merida.”

  26. UNESCO World Heritage (opens in a new tab)

    “An example of the material assimilation and the proof of authenticity of the monument is the way old Roman and Visigoth columns were reused in Islamic architecture.”

  27. journal.equinoxpub.com (opens in a new tab)

    “The use of Roman and Late-antique spolia in the erection of Umayyad infrastructures is extensively documented, from Bilad al-Sham to al-Andalus.”

  28. journal.equinoxpub.com (opens in a new tab)

    “it has been often concluded that there were aesthetic, religious and ideological reasons, as well as strong political needs of legitimation and representation of the Umayyad dynasty.”

  29. journal.equinoxpub.com (opens in a new tab)

    “Here, while spolia seem to have been absent, the capitals designed for its prayer room stand out for their particular characteristics”

  30. mezquita-catedraldecordoba.es — Mezquita fundacional de abderraman i (opens in a new tab)

    “The space, divided into eleven naves perpendicular to the qibla wall, is arranged into a system of superimposed arches.”